Is context dead?

Positionen 122 (2020)

Positionen asks whether contemporary music is liberated or reshaped by the media environment. Including articles on AI and composition and ‘schweigen’/silence as performance.

Eurozine review 5/2020

Subscribe to the Eurozine Review and Newsletter!

Positionen re-evaluates contemporary music’s apparent freedom from context, asking whether it is liberated or reshaped by the media environment.

AI: Composer Genoël von Lilienstern examines artificial intelligence’s impact on recent music production. AI’s musical advancements are set against its shortfalls and questions are raised regarding its overall efficiency, quality and hidden cheap labour. Lilienstern recognizes AI’s success in emulating punk, hardcore and heavy metal but questions its capacity to create something entirely new.

‘Perhaps mankind will eventually harness the high-levels of energy consumption required to get an extremely complex AI model up and running. Or, perhaps, when it does become possible, we would rather deal with completely different issues – pure survival, for example.’

Silence: Nina Guo considers Schweigen – German for ‘being silent’ – as mode of action or non-performance. Some musicians choose not to perform in support of others, as was the case during the 1980s anti-Apartheid protests. Others do so to highlight their own plight, for example the Orquestra Sinfônica Brasiliera, whose members striked against the introduction of individual performance evaluations and threatened dismissals. But non-performers need an audience, Guo argues: ‘For disruption to work, there must be witnesses with thwarted expectations.’ Schweigen ‘becomes the ultimate freedom when artistic expression turns into a commodity.’

Future music: Composer Alexander Schubert and graphic artist Pedro González Fernández have created an avatar named Av3ry that combines natural language processing, algorithmic composition, data crawling and machine learning. Av3ry chats to its audience, composes music and writes poems based on user-specified criteria. Might this be the context-free future of music in the making? Readers are invited to send Telegram messages and respond to the personalized songs received.

More articles from Positionen in EurozinePositionen’s website

Published 31 March 2020
Original in English

Contributed by Positionen © Eurozine


Published in

Share article


Subscribe to know what’s worth thinking about.

Related Articles

Cover for: The materiality of the cloud

The materiality of the cloud

On the hard conditions of soft digitization

Although we often think about the Internet as immaterial, storing the seemingly abstract ones and zeros requires actual, mechanical work. Those who provide the material means are continuously underpaid, thus ‘growth’ and ‘development’ at the centre result in energy depletion in the periphery.

Cover for: Can we track what makes humans happy?

Lithuanian scientists are working on a formula for happiness. Their biometric measurements of feelings and emotional states propose to improve lives. But smart governance linking efficiency with happiness might have repercussions, says Skaidra Trilupaitytė. In a pandemic-tainted world, tracking and advanced lie detector tests could have questionable political uses.