China’s failure to condemn Russia’s war on Ukraine seems to have confirmed the two autocracies’ friendship with no limits. But China has its own stakes in the war-torn country. Ultimately, self-interest will determine how Beijing reacts.
The fate of displaced persons in Ukraine
War in Ukraine has caused about 1.5 million people to become internally displaced. Living conditions are often very difficult for those who flee the war zone in eastern Ukraine, writes Matteo Tacconi; however an informal network of NGOs does what it can to provide support.
When military planes flashed through the spring sky of Luhansk three years ago, and shots were heard in some areas of the city, Elena Dyurugyna, 34, knew that things would only get worse. She was right. Luhansk, Donetsk and the disputed areas in eastern Ukraine would shortly become the theatre of a war between government forces and pro-Russian rebels.
At the time, Elena’s daughter was two years old. “I thought she should not see the war. I had work to finish. As soon as I was done I went to Kyiv. I had no other choice. I had studied in the capital for two years, so I knew it and liked it. My husband had to stay in Luhansk during the worst of the fighting because of his work. Then, in September of 2014, he joined us”.
Elena is a photographer but, when she left Luhansk, she sold her camera and her equipment. She needed money for the journey, to pay the rent and to feed her daughter. At the beginning, in Kyiv, she worked in a MacDonald’s. She didn’t think she would return to her old job, at least not soon. However, she did go back to taking photos. She specialized in photos of children, and has kindergartens and schools among her clients. She takes portraits and she does weddings. Her studio is on the eleventh floor of a building near the Livoberezhna underground station. It is the same address as the head office of the NGO, Krymskaya Diaspora, that was originally established to help those fleeing Crimea, the southern peninsula annexed by Russia in March 2014. They quickly widened the scope of their activities to help displaced persons coming from the crisis in Donbas, which followed shortly after that in Crimea.
NGOs and Internally Displaced Persons
While attending a business course at Krymskaya Diaspora, Elena Dyurugyna was given enough money to buy a camera and some equipment. Krymskaya Diaspora made a studio available to her. “The course was useful. It taught me how to plan, to develop a strategy and how to promote myself. It was also very competitive. We were two hundred and only seventeen of us received funds”.
Krymskaya Diaspora is only one of several NGOs that assist in Kyiv and in the rest of the country those internationally known as Internally Displaced Persons (IDPs). That is, those who have left their homes and moved to other cities and places in Ukraine because of the conflict. Almost all of the NGOs are run by volunteers and obliged to depend on donations. According to the latest data from the UN High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR), which relates to August 2015, the number of IDPs in Ukraine is around 1.5 million. Another one million have gone to Russia, according to the authorities in Moscow.
Even the choice of where to go is politically motivated. This could not be otherwise in a country which has been brutally divided since the Maidan uprising. Those who cross the border feel empathy for Russia, and do not trust the government in Kyiv. “Those who leave the area under the control of the latter, make an informed choice for Ukraine, whereas crossing into Russia would be easier”, says Lesia Lytvynova, co-founder of Frolivska 9/11, another NGO helping displaced persons.
Their life is not easy. “About two years ago, the government passed a law to protect their social rights and to initially allow them financial support”, states Olga Semenova, from the Job Centre for free people, another NGO helping the IDPs. “However, this is bound by technical and bureaucratic steps which, in reality, make things difficult. These people are asked to produce documentation, which mostly they do not have. Therefore, our task is to defend their rights to health services, to work, to kindergarten and to study”.
Resettlement in Kyiv
Employment is the main theme of the organization for which Olga Semenova works, as indicated by the name. “Of the more than 15,000 people who contacted our NGO in our first two years of activity, a third have found work. We have 3,000 companies listed in our database. We have also organized professional courses for 5500 people and enabled fifty startups to get going”.
To act as a bridge between displaced people and companies is in itself hard work. Even more so in a situation such as this, marked by a deep depression. In 2015, the country lost 9.9 GDP points. Also “many of the displaced persons are miserable, frustrated. Out of ten who turn to us, an average of only three are motivated”, Natalia tells us. She works at the Job Centre for free people answering incoming calls on the specially created number.
Frustration feeds on the scarcity of work opportunities, and on a sense of disorientation after having left one’s homeland. Resettlement in Kyiv is not always easy. “At the beginning, local people were supportive towards these people arriving without anything. They were willing to give, sometimes even to give hospitality. But as time passed things gradually changed. The state did not take all the responsibility it should have taken. The management of displaced persons fell to local communities”, says Lesia Lytvynova.
The Frolivska 9/11 storeroom is connected to the road by a window. Anyone who wants can leave food, clothing and toys. A couple in their sixties passes. They have a sack with them from which they take out something for the refugees. They still give.
Published 9 May 2016
Original in Italian
Translated by Osservatorio Balcani e Caucaso
First published by Osservatorio Balcani e Caucaso, 5 May 2016
Contributed by Osservatorio Balcani e Caucaso © Matteo Tacconi / Osservatorio Balcani e Caucaso / EurozinePDF/PRINT
- The war in Ukraine, and the fight for minds
- The shadow of the far Right in Ukraine
- Ordinary global brutalism: Or, made in a Ukrainian superblock
- Underground clubs and startups: On Kyiv's subcultural revolution
- Survivor's guilt: Navigating memory in Ukraine
- Some splashes of colour against the war
- The contradictions of a revolution
- A tale of at least two languages
- Time to reboot the political scene?
- "Take your kids and go away"
Ukraine seems to be more dedicated to European unity than the EU itself. And despite the Kremlin’s best attempts to isolate Russians, a tipping point is inevitable. Until then, we must support cultural workers – their presence is crucial for meaningful change, argues André Wilkens on the podcast.