Populism in power
‘Esprit’ on the alliance between Christians and anti-establishment populists; illiberalism and the transformation of democracy; the EPP and the ‘Hungary question’; and why ‘The Joker’ captures the political zeitgeist.
Eurozine review 7/2020
Il Mulino 1/2020
Subscribe to the Eurozine Review and Newsletter!
There were notable absences among the list of signatories to the statement issued by members of the European People’s Party on 7 April, calling for the expulsion of Fidesz. This lack of unanimity in the EPP on the question of illiberal populism is becoming increasingly untenable, writes Jacques Rupnik in Esprit.
‘For years, the EPP was seen as a pillar of the European project under Franco-German influence. Now, however, the party is finding that central Europe – with Orbán in Hungary, Kurz in Austria and Tusk from Poland – is forcing it to re-examine its political choices.’
Religion: Christians around the world are addressed by populist leaders as custodians of national traditions, and even of the natural order. Yann Raison du Cleuziou argues that the alliance between Christian communities and anti-establishment populists may reveal the roots of the populist turn. Both feel betrayed by mainstream parties and political elites, and both warn against the promotion of sexual diversity and a perceived increased influence of Islam.
At a deeper level, there are ‘profound affinities between populist rhetoric and certain political theologies’. The real promise of populism may be the replenishment of ‘a sacred symbolism of power that has been hollowed out … by the dynamic of political liberalism’.
Political science: Populism emerges in parallel with a transformation of democracy itself, as trust in party representation is eroded and dissent deprecated, argues Nadia Urbinati. Triumphant populist movements exalt national identity over the abstract ideal of human rights, roll back the liberal agenda, dismantle technocratic governance and maintain supremacy through propaganda. Ultimately, ‘populism is not an ideology’ but ‘a “vehicle” to get into power’, yet it is one that invariably leaves its mark on whatever agenda it is supposed to deliver.
Film and TV: The carnivalesque mask of the comic-book villain the Joker, popularized by the recent film, has entered the globalized political imaginary, writes Nicolas Léger. What could be more symbolic of contemporary populism than this ‘contagious and disquieting image’ of a figure riven by ‘nihilistic impulses and desires for change’? Anonymous discontents fighting the political machine are a staple of US popular culture, as Ghislain Benhessa and Nathalie Bittinger show in their history of populism in American films and TV, from D.W. Griffith and Frank Capra to House of Cards and Mr. Robot.
This article was published in cooperation with CAIRN International Edition, translated and edited by Cadenza Academic Translations.
Published 23 April 2020
Original in English
Contributed by Esprit © EurozinePDF/PRINT
Hungarian values and how to misunderstand them
Post-Socialist baggage is sometimes still blamed for Hungarians’ support for an illiberal supermajority. But can a society be expected to democratize when its social institutions have been subjected to decades of attrition?
Corporate capture of the media by the state is not just an eastern European speciality, nor does it take place in an economic vacuum. The 31st European Meeting of Cultural Journals will be focusing on how political interference and market pressure are threatening independent publishing in Europe today.