The fragile individual

Osteuropa 12/2019

Eurozine review 4/2020

Subscribe to the Eurozine Review and Newsletter!

In Osteuropa’s final issue of 2019, entitled ‘The fragile individual: Power and law in eastern Europe’, Marta Bucholc and Maciej Komornik explain the latest phase in the subordination of the judiciary in Poland.

Laws effective since April 2018 on appointments to the newly created disciplinary chamber of the Supreme Court are now being implemented. In November, the ECJ ruled that the independence of the chamber was a matter for the Polish courts. In response to subsequent rulings against the chamber, PiS passed a ‘muzzle law’ at the end of December that penalizes judges who ‘block’ the system. Numerous judges opposed to the reforms have been threatened with disciplinary proceedings and other consequences.

Given the popularity of the reforms – the fruit of a propaganda campaign in which Kaczyński himself participates – it is unlikely that Andrzej Duda, the president, will block the laws as he did in 2017. Only the EU can prevent PiS from taking the final step towards the abolition of judicial independence in Poland, warn Bucholc and Komornik.

Polish politics

The Sejm and Senate elections in October brought greater polarization, writes Reinhold Vetter in a survey of Poland’s political landscape. Fissures have deepened between the east and west of the nation, between town and country, and between generations and professional groups. PiS is intent on proceeding with its national conservative, Catholic agenda. However, the days are over when it could force laws through parliament, particularly after losing its majority in the upper house. Greater conflicts are foreseeable, not least if Poland’s economic growth begins to slow.

György Konrád

A dossier on György Konrád (1933–2019), including a survey of his life and thought by Ferenc Laczó. Konrád’s ‘sceptical utopianism’, writes Laczó, combined distrust of state authority and obligatory collectivism with a deep belief in the moral potential of the individual. With the deaths of Konrád and Ágnes Heller last summer, an era has come to an end: ‘Despite their broad intellectual horizon and their political and moral integrity, Hungarian liberal intellectuals failed to bring forth a new generation of liberal sons and daughters.’ They are partly to blame, however. Elitism and in-fighting, together with political misjudgements after ’89 – in Konrád’s case, ill-informed support for Serbia in the Balkan wars and, paradoxically, the US invasion of Iraq – did them no favours.

Read also Gábor Csordás’s farewell to György Konrád, ‘A dream is not nothing‘.

1989

The processes set in motion by the disintegration of the socialist economy in eastern Europe eluded all analytical frameworks, writes the historian of the Soviet Union Karl Schlögel. It was a time of ‘wild thinking’, in which received ideas were reconsidered and values re-assessed. We are still living through this troubled era.

More articles from Osteuropa in Eurozine; Osteuropa’s website

This article is part of the 4/2020 Eurozine review. Click here to subscribe to our weekly newsletter, so to stay tuned on reviews and our latest publishing.

Published 16 March 2020
Original in English
First published by Eurozine

Related Articles

Cover for: Legacies of 1989 for dissent today

What are the legacies of dissent, thirty years after 1989? Two places to look are the 2011 Arab Spring and Armenia’s revolts in 2018. They both teach different lessons about establishing the interpersonal conditions for successful non-violent rebellions and restoring social trust in an illiberal age when authoritarians use ‘hybrid warfare’ tactics to disrupt democracies from the inside.

Cover for: Eastern exodus

Eastern members of the EU are experiencing extreme depopulation, due to a combination of mass emigration and low birth rates. Nationalist governments pander to patriotic sentiments but consistently fail to address the social and political problems which drive young adults westwards.

Discussion