The sole intention of pleasing

L'Espill 60/2019

The Catalan journal reflects on the position of the refugee in society, and also delves into kitsch.


Values based on imitation

The term kitsch originated in a South German expression for doing something clumsily, or passing off something old as new, writes Anacleto Ferrer in a dossier on Kitsch in the Spring issue of L’Espill. However, he associates the emergence of Kitsch as concept with the notions of modernity put forward by such as Baudelaire, who first presented an idea of beauty that could be both ‘infernal and divine’, ‘from Heaven or rising from the abyss’. In contrast to stable notions of beauty that had lasted since Aristotle, this opened the gates to a more fluid perception of ‘circumstantial beauty’.

A world of uncertain aesthetic values has provided ‘propitious ground’ for the emergence of ‘the vast region of kitsch’, expressing ‘a system of values based on imitation, that undertakes things with the sole intention of pleasing, of “looking good”, and replaces the ethical category that imposes upon an artist the obligation of creating a “good work” with one of making “pleasing work”’, combined with ‘a strong dose of self-satisfied hedonism’.

“…a system of values based on imitation…”
Photo from pxhere

Ferrer goes on to analyse the characteristics of modern kitsch, highlighting a ‘great capacity for emotional suggestion’ as a hallmark, and its different categories, from grandiose official art projects to more domestic items. Finally, he identifies prime examples of kitsch in his own setting of Valencia, especially in the ostentatious projects created in the pre-2008 boom: traffic roundabouts with giant sculptures and elaborate street furniture. ‘The crown jewel of local official techno-kitsch’, however, is the vast complex called the City of Arts and Sciences designed by Santiago Calatava, ‘a totally disproportionate project of limited functionality, which requires an excessive operating budget … a kind of architectural Disneyland, an advertising icon.’ Buildings such as this, which disregard utilitarian considerations, are ‘purely the imposition of an effect’.

In the refugee experience

Victoria Saenz draws on her experience as a volunteer in a refugee camp in Greece to reflect on the position of the refugee in our societies. International institutions, ‘refugee studies’ and even humanitarian workers, she writes, ‘tend to see refugees as a homogenous mass without a will of their own’. Whereas Ethiopians, Nepalese, and especially Kurds and Arab Syrians all had very distinct experiences and views of their situation, she found. Listening to the refugees themselves ‘has the potential to make us deconstruct and rethink our political realities and questions of identity in a way that goes beyond nations’ Saenz writes.

This article is part of our 11/2019 Eurozine review. Click here to subscribe to our reviews, and you also can subscribe to our newsletter and get the bi-weekly updates about latest publications and news on partner journals.

Published 25 June 2019
Original in English
First published by Eurozine

© Eurozine


Related Articles

Cover for: The right to truth denied

Appeals to the European Court of Human Rights to enforce the ‘right to truth’ in connection with the Franco regime and the Katyń massacre have been refused on procedural grounds. A long history of delayed justice has become a permanent case of justice denied, argues human rights lawyer Grażyna Baranowska.

Cover for: From a high vantage point

‘Human Flow’ is Ai Weiwei’s film on the plight of refugees in 23 countries. The artist goes further than Picasso, who never got as far as Guernica himself, but did Ai Weiwei lose his way whilst making the film? Georges Didi-Huberman insists that human suffering on this scale calls for a much bolder critical spirit.