Latest Articles


24.04.2015
Manuel Arias Maldonado

Podemos: Much more than just a marriage of minds

Founded in 2014, Podemos already leads opinion polls across Spain. But accusations that it is treating the country as a gigantic piece of fieldwork and conjecture as to its rootedness in political theory tend to be wide of the mark, writes Manuel Arias Maldonado. [English version added] [ more ]

24.04.2015
Eric Bonse

German Europe's ascendancy

23.04.2015
Michail Dimitrakopoulos

Syriza and the destiny of modern Greece

22.04.2015
Bill Frelick, Judith Sunderland

Humanitarian rhetoric, inhumane treatment

22.04.2015
Anne Applebaum, Lukasz Pawlowski

Russia: A sick man with a gun

New Issues


20.04.2015

Samtiden | 1/2015

20.04.2015

Polar | 18 (2015)

Politik der Lebensformen
20.04.2015

Spilne | 1 (2015)

Maidan: A left perspective

Eurozine Review


22.04.2015
Eurozine Review

Capitalism's animal spirits

"openDemocracy" condemns the European Union's inhumane treatment of migrants; "Kultura Liberalna" talks to Anne Applebaum; in "Blätter", Rolf Hosfeld marks the centenary of the Armenian genocide; "Esprit" re-reads Kostas Axelos on the destiny of modern Greece; "Varlik" remembers Yasar Kemal; "Letras Libres" contemplates a concept of tolerance turned upside down, after 10 years of cartoon controversy; "Spilne" rejects the pro-/anti-westernism surrounding the Maidan protests; "Samtiden" takes stock of last year's Norwegian novels; and "Polar" critiques a new DIY mentality in the search for alternative ways of life.

08.04.2015
Eurozine Review

Everything is PR

25.03.2015
Eurozine Review

Stop press: The world will not end!

11.03.2015
Eurozine Review

Putting the aesthetics back into politics

25.02.2015
Eurozine Review

The right to blaspheme



http://www.eurozine.com/articles/2011-05-02-newsitem-en.html
http://mitpress.mit.edu/0262025248
http://www.eurozine.com/about/who-we-are/contact.html
http://www.eurozine.com/articles/2009-12-02-newsitem-en.html

My Eurozine


If you want to be kept up to date, you can subscribe to Eurozine's rss-newsfeed or our Newsletter.

Articles
Share |

Buying a kidney

Thousands of Europeans die annually waiting for a new kidney, heart or liver. At the same time, the black-market trade in organs is thriving, as a recent scandal in Germany has shown. So should organ trading be legalized? Slavenka Drakulic, herself a two-time kidney transplant patient, argues the pros and cons.

That morning, a telephone call cut my life in half – into a life before the kidney transplant and a life after it. It was 16 February 1986, a cold and stormy day, when the call from Boston's New England Deaconess Hospital came through. I was 37 years old, divorced, with a teenage daughter. I was living in Yugoslavia and after six years of surviving on a haemodialysis machine, connected to it for four hours every second day, I had been wondering if there would ever be a transplant.

Eighteen years later, in 2004, I got another call, this time from Rhode Island Hospital. After the rejection of the first kidney and another four years of waiting on machines – another chance! And a very special one at that: this time I was to receive a kidney from an altruistic, non-related, living donor.

I was shocked when I heard that. An unknown person who gives away her kidney to a stranger! How is that possible? Later, after the surgery, I met my donor Christine Swenson, a young nurse and mother of two. I asked her what her motivation was. Christine replied that she had no particular reason except the wish to help. People tend to assume almost automatically that such an act of extreme goodness must be motivated by money – or religious beliefs. Neither applied in Christine's case. Having written a book about people like Christine, I know that they are ordinary people and that is precisely why their gifts are so precious.



Why aren't there enough organs to meet the need for transplants? Why are people sentenced to premature death because they have to wait too long? In Germany, a recent scandal involving manipulated medical records revealed the extent of the illegal trade in kidneys and other organs. As a story in Der Spiegel showed, both the seller and the buyer of the kidney can be regarded as victims. A Russian immigrant in Israel, Vera Shevdko, sold her kidney for 8100 euros to an elderly German man named Walter. Vera is a victim of poverty with whom it is easy to sympathize. Yet Walter, the buyer, is also a victim: a victim of an inefficient health system. If you are told that you have only a few months to live if you don't get a transplant – and you don't have any chance of getting one – wouldn't you look for another solution, even if it is illegal? There is not one single patient on a waiting list who has not entertained the idea of buying an organ. The tampering with waiting lists in respectable German hospitals just confirms the scope of the problem.

Europe's compulsory health insurance system is something to be proud of. However, that doesn't mean that it works perfectly. In Europe, healthcare is institutionalized rather than privatized. On the other hand, patients here expect much more of medical institutions than, for example, in the US. Since organs can be harvested only from a brain-dead person on a life-support machine or from a living donor, there aren't enough organs to go around. Why, then, is there no legal market for organs? Rare cases of corruption and trafficking reveal what everybody knows: the market already exists. But it is a black market, in private hands and uncontrolled. Wouldn't it make sense to legalize it?

I find this question legitimate. In the last decade, much has been written on the subject, especially in the US. The core of the controversy has been well described by Sally Satel, an advocate of a legalized market, a medical doctor and a transplant patient herself. Is it really more ethical, she asks, to die while waiting for an organ than to buy one? The arguments against marketing organs are well known. Above all they express concern for the poor, the most likely sellers. Pro-market advocates counter that, if controlled by the state, donors could be compensated with free education or free medical care.

Numerous websites now act as a source for people seeking organs. One such is www.matchingdonors.com – here, however, both the donor and the recipient must sign a legally binding document stipulating that no money or other benefits have been exchanged before the transplant is carried out. America is indeed different from Europe in this respect: there seems to be less suspicion there.

Would a market for organs even be possible within Europe's socialized healthcare system? The European system is devised to benefit everyone equally, not only those with money; this principle is what makes it a just one. To introduce money into this kind of system would run counter to the humanistic tradition and ideals that distinguish Europe from other parts of the world.

However, the price is high. In Germany alone, almost three thousand people die every year waiting for a transplant. These figures show how necessary it is to introduce measures within the existing possibilities. More investment in transplant medicine will reduce the need for a black market. But this would require additional effort involving the whole of society. This will be impossible unless it is clear to everyone that the alternative is not only a miserable life on machines, but also the premature death of many patients. The new draft law in Germany includes two key changes: there would be no need to ask relatives of a deceased person for permission for a donation; and the waiting time for a patient would start from the first day of dialysis. If the law gets passed, it would probably shorten the waiting lists considerably. But it would also be necessary to introduce more rigorous means of control to avoid corruption. Recent scandals should set the alarm bells ringing and can serve as an argument in favour of such changes. But the influence of the pharmaceutical lobbies, which profit from the existence of expensive dialysis, ought not to be underestimated. One patient on haemodialysis costs around 80,000 euros a year – a transplant costs less than half that.

Once you have received your kidney, nobody asks what happens then. Do you live long and happily ever after? A lot of care and effort is needed to balance medication in such a way as to prevent an organ from being rejected. Here, the Germans have a remarkable record: if you do end up getting a kidney, you are pretty safe. This is no small achievement. As a patient who has had two transplants, I know this only too well.


 



Published 2012-09-07


Original in English
First published in Süddeutsche Zeitung 30.08.2012 (German version); Eurozine (English version)

© Slavenka Drakulic
© Eurozine
 

Focal points     click for more

The politics of privacy

http://www.eurozine.com/comp/focalpoints/privacy.html
The Snowden leaks and the ensuing NSA scandal made the whole world debate privacy and data protection. Now the discussion has entered a new phase - and it's all about policy. A focal point on the politics of privacy: claiming a European value. [more]

Beyond Fortress Europe

http://www.eurozine.com/comp/focalpoints/lawborder.html
The fate of migrants attempting to enter Fortress Europe has triggered a new European debate on laws, borders and human rights. A focal point featuring reportage alongside articles on policy and memory. With contributions by Fabrizio Gatti, Seyla Benhabib and Alessandro Leogrande. [more]

Russia in global dialogue

http://www.eurozine.com/comp/focalpoints/eurocrisis.html
In the two decades after the end of the Cold War, intellectual interaction between Russia and Europe has intensified. It has not, however, prompted a common conversation. The focal point "Russia in global dialogue" seeks to fuel debate on democracy, society and the legacy of empire. [more]

Ukraine in focus

http://www.eurozine.com/comp/focalpoints/publicsphere.html
Ten years after the Orange Revolution, Ukraine is in the throes of yet another major struggle. Eurozine provides commentary on events as they unfold and further articles from the archive providing background to the situation in today's Ukraine. [more]

Eurozine BLOG

On the Eurozine BLOG, editors and Eurozine contributors comment on current affairs and events. What's behind the headlines in the world of European intellectual journals?
Eurozine
Eurozine Gallery: TIME top ten photos of 2014

http://www.eurozine.com/blog/
Massimo Sestini's aerial shot of a boat containing at least 500 people attempting to cross the Mediterranean Sea, included in the current exhibition in the Eurozine Gallery, has been named one of the top ten photos of 2014 by TIME magazine. [more]

CHeFred
A master of the daily grind

http://www.eurozine.com/blog/
On Sunday 30 November, Turkish publisher Osman Deniztekin died, just a few weeks after having been diagnosed with leukemia. He was 65. In memoriam. [more]

Time to Talk     click for more

Time to Talk, a network of European Houses of Debate, has partnered up with Eurozine to launch an online platform. Here you can watch video highlights from all TTT events, anytime, anywhere.
Dessislava Gavrilova, Jo Glanville et al.
The role of literature houses in protecting the space for free expression

http://www.eurozine.com/timetotalk/european-literature-houses-meeting-2014/
This summer, Time to Talk partner Free Word, London hosted a debate on the role that literature houses play in preserving freedom of expression both in Europe and globally. Should everyone get a place on the podium? Also those representing the political extremes? [more]

Support Eurozine     click for more

If you appreciate Eurozine's work and would like to support our contribution to the establishment of a European public sphere, see information about making a donation.

Vacancies at Eurozine     click for more

There are currently no positions available.

Editor's choice     click for more

Felix Stalder
Digital solidarity

http://www.eurozine.com/articles/2014-02-26-stalder-en.html
As the culture and institutions of the Gutenberg Galaxy wane, Felix Stalder looks to commons, assemblies, swarms and weak networks as a basis for remaking society in a more inclusive and diverse way. The aim being to expand autonomy and solidarity at the same time. [more]

Literature     click for more

Olga Tokarczuk
A finger pointing at the moon

http://www.eurozine.com/articles/2014-01-16-tokarczuk-en.html
Our language is our literary destiny, writes Olga Tokarczuk. And "minority" languages provide a special kind of sanctuary too, inaccessible to the rest of the world. But, there again, language is at its most powerful when it reaches beyond itself and starts to create an alternative world. [more]

Piotr Kiezun, Jaroslaw Kuisz
Literary perspectives special: Witold Gombrowicz

http://www.eurozine.com/articles/2013-08-16-kuisz-en.html
The recent publication of the private diary of Witold Gombrowicz provides unparalleled insight into the life of one of Poland's great twentieth-century novelists and dramatists. But this is not literature. Instead: here he is, completely naked. [more]

Literary perspectives
The re-transnationalization of literary criticism

http://www.eurozine.com/comp/literaryperspectives.html
Eurozine's series of essays aims to provide an overview of diverse literary landscapes in Europe. Covered so far: Croatia, Sweden, Austria, Estonia, Ukraine, Northern Ireland, Slovenia, the Netherlands and Hungary. [more]

Debate series     click for more

Europe talks to Europe

http://www.eurozine.com/comp/europetalkstoeurope.html
Nationalism in Belgium might be different from nationalism in Ukraine, but if we want to understand the current European crisis and how to overcome it we need to take both into account. The debate series "Europe talks to Europe" is an attempt to turn European intellectual debate into a two-way street. [more]

Conferences     click for more

Eurozine emerged from an informal network dating back to 1983. Since then, European cultural magazines have met annually in European cities to exchange ideas and experiences. Around 100 journals from almost every European country are now regularly involved in these meetings.
Law and Border. House Search in Fortress Europe
The 26th European Meeting of Cultural Journals
Conversano, 3-6 October 2014

http://www.eurozine.com/comp/conversano2014.html
Eurozine's 2014 conference in southern Italy, not far from Lampedusa, addressed both EU refugee and immigration policies and intellectual partnerships across the Mediterranean. Speakers included Italian investigative journalist Fabrizio Gatti and Moroccan feminist and Nobel Peace Prize nominee Rita El Khayat. [more]

Multimedia     click for more

http://www.eurozine.com/comp/multimedia.html
Multimedia section including videos of past Eurozine conferences in Vilnius (2009) and Sibiu (2007). [more]


powered by publick.net