Latest Articles


21.05.2012
Jacques Rupnik

The euro crisis: Central European lessons

Central European responses to the euro crisis have been marked by a total absence of regional solidarity, writes Jacques Rupnik. Differing national situations explain varying perceptions of the crisis' risks and remedies and can be seen in terms of political lessons learned. [French version added] [ more ]

21.05.2012
Kenan Malik

To name the unnameable

21.05.2012
Eurozine News Item

New Eurozine partner: Zarez

18.05.2012
Bo Isenberg

Critique and crisis

16.05.2012
Claus Leggewie

Continuities denied


New Issues


Eurozine Review


09.05.2012
Eurozine Review

Sudden and slow-acting poisons

"Mittelweg 36" re-reads Jean Améry on torture; "Free Speech Debate" takes on hate speech laws and superinjunctions; "Esprit" enters the French debate on incest; "New Humanist" says rationalism won't stop witch hunters; "Merkur" makes the case for binding quotas for women; "Wespennest" calls for more women essayists; "Osteuropa" considers the future of European security; "Lettera internazionale" decolonizes the European mind; and "Sarajevo Notebook" seeks out the golden oldies of Roma pop.

18.04.2012
Eurozine Review

Not a Prospero in sight

21.03.2012
Eurozine Review

To hell in a handbasket

07.03.2012
Eurozine Review

There's no neutrality of living



http://www.eurozine.com/articles/2011-05-02-newsitem-en.html
http://mitpress.mit.edu/0262025248
http://www.eurozine.com/about/who-we-are/contact.html
http://www.n-ost.org
http://www.eurozine.com/articles/2009-12-02-newsitem-en.html

My Eurozine


If you want to be kept up to date, you can subscribe to Eurozine's rss-newsfeed or our Newsletter.

Articles
Share |


Za dušmanot, dušata, duhovnosta i duhovitosta

Tema: Prijatel-dušman, spodelen prostor, razedineto opštestvo


Bitola mi se dopaga poveke od Skopje - vosklikna mojata sopruga, inaku stranec vo ovaa naša zemja, pri prvata zaednička poseta na gradot pod Pelister. Ne sum nekoj zakoraven skopjanec. Iskreno, mislam deka da se bide poubav od Skopje i ne e nekoja posebna turistička preporaka za bilo koj grad, najmalku za Bitola. Sepak pobarav objasnuvanje. Odgovorot me zbuni i me zamisli: Vo Bitola ima dzamija vo glavnata ulica,

Ovaa bitolska epizoda me vrati dvaeset i kusur godini nazad, koga mojata odluka da studiram orientalistika vo Saraevo naide na buica prašanja od bliskite i prijatelite. Zošto tokmu orientalistika? Nemav logičen odgovor togaš, a go nemam nitu sega. No toa i ne e prašanje na logikata i razumot, tuku na čuvstvoto, ona vrodeno čuvstvo na ljubopitnost koe ušte od ranoto detstvo me tera da zirkam naokolu, da gi nasetuvam horizonite na drugite, da pravam kusi ekskurzii po nivnite svetovi, srekavajki se so različni veruvanja, stravovi i nadeži. Jas sum duhoven voajer i ne se sramam od taa dobronamerna natraplivost koja nikomu ne naštetuva, a mene mi da go dava čuvstvoto na postojano zbogatuvanje bez poseduvanje, na postojano davanje bez obezličuvanje.

Ne znam kako bi izgledal svetot so edna nacija, vera ili jazik, no znam deka jas ne bi možel da živeam vo takov svet.

Patem, na studiite ja zapoznav svojata denešna sopruga, a gledano od denešna perspektiva Bitola mi izgleda navistina poubava od Skopje. Megu nas kažano, ako e samo za toa, vredeše da se studira orientalistika.

Od orientalistikata mi ostanaa i drugi polezni raboti. Arapskite poslovici, na primer. Koj bara ke najde - veli edna od niv. Ne e nekoja golema mudrost, neli? No kolkumina od nas baraat ? Što očekuvame da najdeme ako voopšto ne barame? Znaeme li voopšto da barame? Ili čekame nekoj drug da ni go servira našeto nesoznaeno iskustvo za Drugiot, najčesto kako veke skisnata mangza od koja ke ne zaboli stomakot.

Prv pat vo životot otidov vo Debar vo zreli godini, na pokana od eden moj kolega, lokalen Albanec, koj poveke pati insistiraše da mu bidam gostin. Postojano naogav nekoe opravduvanje, poveke pomalku dobro - sekoe opravduvanje da ne se otide vo Debar e dobro opravduvanje - se dodeka ne ja dobiv pokanata što ne možev da ja odbijam: Te vodam na albanska svadba. Vo mene se razbudi ona palavo dete što cel život talka po gradinite na nečii drugi identiteti i go mava so pračka ona staro čičence što se guši vo dobro poznatite dlabočini na indiferentnosta koja nužno se raga vo baruštinata na poznatoto. Da, otidov vo Debar, na albanska svadba. Bev edinstven Drug na svadbata, edinstven što se vika poinaku i koj zboruva na drug jazik.

Kako si pominav? Što da vi kažam? Se čuvstvuvav navistina mnogu nelagodno cela večer. Svatovite se natprevaruvaa koj poveke ke mi ugodi, mojata čaša i činijata postojano bea polni, a zgora na se lugeto koi dotogaš zboruvaa na svoj, za mene nerazbirliv jazik, počnaa da zboruvaat na mojot jazik.

Beduinite imaat pravo : koj bara ke najde.

Životot e sepak nešto drugo, mi veli ona starče vo mene koe sedi so pruženi noze pred televizorot vo sobata i gi niže, kako brojanici, site informativni emisii na nacionalnite televizii. No što e vsušnost životot, prašuva momčeto : predodredenost ili izbor? Otvoren pat ili zatvoren krug?

Velat deka iskustvoto raga mudrost. Jas poveke veruvam vo naivnosta na decata. Odbivam da stanam iskusen. Sakam da ostanam naiven!

Možebi toa dete vo mene me naveduva da mislam deka postoi nekoja tajna vrska megu zborovite duša i dušman. Znam, mi ostana od studiite, zborot dušman e od persisko poteklo i znači neprijatel. Vo mojot misloven svet, pak, zborot duša e vrzan za najgolemata vrednost na čoveštvoto: Ljubovta. Možeš da se sakaš i samiot sebe, no vistinska ljubov e koga sakaš nekoj drug. Dušmanot postoi najprvo vo našata duša, a duri potoa vo sosedstvoto. Treba dušmanot da go izbrkame od dušata, za da sosedot stane ona što e : dobro poznato lice koe možebi zboruva i se moli poinaku, no se smee i plače isto kako i nie.

Site go spodeluvame identičniot i nedeliv prostor na čovekovata beznačajnost i minlivost. Edinstvenata uteha za našata zaednička ništožnost i možebi edinstvenata smisla na postoenjeto e vozdignuvanjeto nad prostorot i talkanjeto vo sferite na duhovnoto. Tuka nema granici. Tuka nikoj ne posegnuva po prostorot na drugiot zatoa što duhovnosta ne se osvojuva i brani so oružje, na nejzinite vrvovi ne može da se nabie ničie zname ili izgradi spomenik. Taa ne bara vizi, nitu se interesira za imeto vo ličnata karta. Taa e nadvor od vremeto i prostorot i zatoa e večna.

Na turski glagolot dušmek znači - da padneš. I toa mi ostanalo od orientalistikata. Zborot dušmek nema nikakva etimološka vrska so zborot dušman no vo mojot svet na analogii i asocijacii ja odreduva samata suština na poimot dušman. Da bideš nekomu dušman, znači da padneš, da se strupoliš, da se peplosaš vo kalta na obezdušenosta.

Spasot e vo dušata. Kade ima duša, nema dušmani i nema dušmek, nema paganje.

Kako da izbegame od dušmanot vo nas, da ne padneme vo stapicata na netrpelivost kon Drugite vo vreme koga problemot na različnite identiteti se postavuva kako planetarno prašanje? Kako da si ja sočuvame dušata od dušmanot koj se krie vo sekoj od nas ?

Sekoj treba da si go odbere svojot pat. Jas mislam deka edno od najdobrite sredstva za izdignuvanje od kalta na dušmanlakot do visinite na duhovnosta vodi preku - duhovitosta.

Ednostavno, potrebno e vo cvrsto izgradeniot sistem na etničkata, verskata jazičnata i sekoja druga isklučivost da se vmetne - virus. Toj virus treba da bide kombiniran koktel od relativizacija na identitetite, ismejuvanje na različnosta svatena kako sudbina i potenciranje na sitnoto i navidum nebitnoto, nasproti rabotite koi se činat golemi, suštinski, istoriski.

So drugi zborovi: zezajte se, bre, luge, so razlikite koi se prirodni, a koi nekoi sakaat veštački da gi pretvorat vo prostor kade što vladee dušmanlakot. Ima li nešto poprirodno od duhovitosta i smeata, duri i koga stanuva zbor za "smrtno seriozni" prašanja.

Se sekavam na eden primer od predvoeno Saraevo, vo vreme koga potenciranjeto na razlikite megu lugeto što so vekovi živeele zaedno neminovno vodeše kon konfrontacija. Vo toa Saraevo, eden den, na zidot na glavnata gradska pošta osamna grafit: Ova e Srbija.
Sledniot den nekoj so sprej go isprskal grafitot i pod nego napišal: Ova e Hrvatska. I toj grafit ja doživea sudbinata na prethodniot, a na zidot gordo stoeše: Ova e Bosna.
Četvrtiot den i toj grafit beše izbrišan. Pod nego, nekoj so crven sprej napišal: Budali nizaedni...ova e pošta!
Toj grafit nikoj ne go izbriša.
Toa e toa: virusot na duhovitosta koj go razara dušmalakot i ja otvara dušata. Jas vo avtorot na posledniot grafit prepoznav dete, možebi i vozrasen čovek, no sepak dete koe na golemite, natmureni i smrtno seriozni čičkovci i ponekoja tetkica od televiziskiot dnevnik im veli da go pogrebaat dušmanot vo sebe za da si ja spasat dušata, pred da bide predocna.

Bidejki smrtno serioznite prašanja megu različnite identiteti seriozno vodat vo smrt.

Posledniot grafit so svojata naivnost ne ja spreči vojnata, ke rečete. Taka e! No toa ne znači deka virusot na duhovitosta ne bil dobar, tuku deka ne bil vo dovolni količini. Koga sekoj graganin bi produciral makar po eden siten virus na duhovitost protiv isklučivosta, sistemot sostaven od vrzani spirali na isklučivost bi se raspadnal sam od sebe.

I da završam od tamu od kade što počnav: prošetkata po Širok Sokak vo Bitola. Otkako se vooduševi na bitolskiot multikulturalizam, mojata sopruga za mig zastana pred Saat-kulata.

- Ova e Saat kula? - me praša začudeno.
- Gledaš i samata.
- Čekaj, pa Saat kulata e spomenik na islamskata arhitektura- reče, ušte poveke začudeno
- Tolku i jas naučiv od studiite.
- Pa zošto togaš ste i stavile krst na vrvot?

Go očekuvav ova no ne znaev što da odgovaram. Pomisliv za mig, pa rekov:

- Da bide povisoka i povozvišena.

Virusot na duhovitosta ne može da ja relativizira gluposta, no može da ja prikaže vo vistinskoto svetlo. A toa e veke dovolno za početok.

 



Published 2007-07-13


Original in Macedonian
First published in Roots 21-22 (2007)

Contributed by Roots
© Pajo Avirovic/Roots
© Eurozine
 

Focal points     click for more

The EU: Broken or just broke?

http://www.eurozine.com/comp/focalpoints/eurocrisis.html
Brought on by the global economic recession, the eurocrisis has been exacerbated by serious faults built into the monetary union. In a new Eurozine focal point, contributors discuss whether the EU is not only broke, but also broken -- and if so, whether Europe's leaders are up to the task of fixing it. [more]

European histories (2): Concord and conflict

http://www.eurozine.com/comp/focalpoints/eurohistories2.html
Broadening the question of a common European narrative beyond the East-West divide. How are contested interpretations of historical and recent events activated in the present, uniting and dividing European societies? [more]

Changing media -- Media in change

Media change is about more than just the "newspaper crisis" and the iPad: property law, privacy, free speech and the functioning of the public sphere are all affected. On a field experiencing profound and constant transformation. [more]

Support Eurozine     click for more

If you appreciate Eurozine's work and would like to support our contribution to the establishment of a European public sphere, see information about making a donation.

Editor's choice     click for more

Slavenka Drakulic
The tune of the future
Italy: old Europe, new Europe, changing Europe

http://www.eurozine.com/articles/2012-03-15-drakulic-en.html
Travelling around Italy, Slavenka Drakulic observes one kind of Europe being replaced by another. Instead of attempting to conserve the cultural past, we should accept that migration will adapt much of what we consider "European" to its own image. [more]

Klaus-Michael Bogdal
Europe invents the Gypsies
The dark side of modernity

Social segregation, cultural appropriation: the six-hundred-year history of the European Roma, as recorded in literature and art, represents the underside of the European subject's self-invention as agent of civilising progress in the world. [more]

George Prevelakis
Greece: The history behind the collapse

Greece's economic crisis has its roots in a political pact dating back to the foundation of the modern state. The threat posed to Europe by the Greek breakdown is less contagion than a wave of anti-western feeling. [more]

Debate series     click for more

Europe talks to Europe

http://www.eurozine.com/comp/europetalkstoeurope.html
Nationalism in Belgium might be different from nationalism in Ukraine, but if we want to understand the current European crisis and how to overcome it we need to take both into account. The debate series "Europe talks to Europe" is an attempt to turn European intellectual debate into a two-way street. [more]

Literature     click for more

Steve Sem-Sandberg
Even nameless horrors must be named

http://www.eurozine.com/articles/2011-09-23-semsandberg-en.html
It is high time to lift the aesthetic state of emergency that has surrounded witness literature for so long, writes Steve Sem-Sandberg. It is not important who writes, nor even what their motives are. What counts is the "literary efficiency". [more]

Literary perspectives
The re-transnationalization of literary criticism

Eurozine's series of essays aims to provide an overview of diverse literary landscapes in Europe. Covered so far: Croatia, Sweden, Austria, Estonia, Ukraine, Northern Ireland, Slovenia, the Netherlands and Hungary. [more]

Behind the headlines     click for more

Mykola Riabchuk
Tymoshenko: Wake-up call for the EU

The EU shouldn't be surprised by the Tymoshenko verdict: its support of anything nominally reformist has been perceived as acceptance of a range of repressions, argues Mykola Riabchuk. [more]

Conferences     click for more

Eurozine emerged from an informal network dating back to 1983. Since then, European cultural magazines have met annually in European cities to exchange ideas and experiences. Around 100 journals from almost every European country are now regularly involved in these meetings.
Arrivals/Departures: European harbour cities as places of migration
The 24th European Meeting of Cultural Journals
Hamburg, 14-16 September 2012

http://www.eurozine.com/comp/hamburg2012.html
Harbour cities as places of movement, of immigration and emigration, as places of inclusion and exclusion, develop distinct modes of being that not only reflect different cultural traditions and political and social self-conceptions, but also communicate how they see themselves as part of the structure that is "Europe". The 2012 Eurozine conference will explore how European societies deal variously with the cultural legacy of the "harbour city". [more]

Multimedia     click for more

http://www.eurozine.com/comp/multimedia.html
Multimedia section including videos of past Eurozine conferences in Vilnius (2009) and Sibiu (2007). [more]


powered by publick.net