Latest Articles


08.02.2010
AC Grayling, Tzvetan Todorov

How to defend the Enlightenment

"To say that reason is only desiccating and too dry is a dangerous caricature. No less dangerous is to eliminate the place for arts, for myth, which is a different kind of knowledge of the world." Tzvetan Todorov in conversation with AC Grayling about his new book, "In Defence of the Enlightenment". [ more ]

05.02.2010
Christopher Newfield

The structure and silence of the cognitariat

05.02.2010
Lucas Zeise

Banking regulation? Malfunction!

04.02.2010
Michael Bywater

Fair game


New Issues


Eurozine Review


27.01.2010
Eurozine Review

Erring on the side of secrecy

"Index on Censorship" covers another chapter of the fruitless cartoon debate; "Glänta" pays attention to nature; "RiLi" picks over the debris of aviation's dreams; "Multitudes" calls on cognitarians of all lands; "L'Homme" misses women's lib in the 68 anniversary; "Edinburgh Review" takes Kafka's Prague down from the top shelf; "NZ" says Russian readers never had it so good as during Glasnost; "Osteuropa" doubts there's anything left in the pan-Slavic idea; "Mehr Licht" appeals to philosophy's transformative potential; and "Vikerkaar" uncovers the ancient origins of the telenovela.

13.01.2010
Eurozine Review

Charismatic megafauna

16.12.2009
Eurozine Review

Extra-parliamentary opposition 2.0

02.12.2009
Eurozine Review

And ultimately to forget

18.11.2009
Eurozine Review

Nuclear Bonapartism



http://mitpress.mit.edu/0262025248
http://www.social-europe.eu/category/good-society-debate/
http://www.wespennest.at/
http://www.eurozine.com/articles/2009-12-02-newsitem-en.html
http://www.eurozine.com/about/who-we-are/contact.html
http://www.n-ost.de/cms/
http://www.blaetter.de/kasino-kapitalismus.php
http://www.resetdoc.org

My Eurozine


If you want to be kept up to date, you can subscribe to Eurozine's rss-newsfeed or our Newsletter.

Articles

Islamic evangelism

Islam in Europe

It is a mistake to think that religous and political radicalism among European Muslims is a mere import from the cultures and conflicts of the Middle East. It is above all a consequence of the globalization and Westernization of Islam, writes Olivier Roy.

Many believe that religious revival and political radicalism among Europe's Muslims reflects the traditions and conflicts of the Middle East or the wider Muslim world. But Islamic Salafism (fundamentalist religious radicalism) is above all a consequence of the globalization and Westernization of Islam, and of the decoupling of culture and religion more generally.

New book


Krzysztof Michalski (ed.), Conditions of European Solidarity, vol. II: Religion in the New Europe, Central European University Press 2006.


All forms of religious fundamentalism rely on the notion of a "pure" religion independent of cultural variations and influences. Today's Islamic revival shares the dogmatism, communitarianism, and scripturalism of American evangelist movements: both reject culture, philosophy, and even theology to favour a literalist reading of the sacred texts and an immediate understanding of truth through individual faith.

Recent religious books published in the West reflect this, with titles like What is Islam?, What Does It Mean To Be A Muslim?, and How To Experience Islam? It is easy to fast during Ramadan in Afghanistan, Pakistan, and Egypt, even if one does not want to. But a Muslim living in Europe is confronted with the necessity of objectifying the religion. The ulemas (religious scholars) are useless for believers, who are searching for purely religious criteria that are no longer linked to a given culture.

Focal Point: Post-secular Europe?


Is religion a public or a private matter? Can there be such a thing as a European Islam? If so, what characterizes it? What role can religion -- or religions -- play when it comes to the emergence of a European solidarity? In a series of articles, Eurozine focuses on post-secular tendencies and religion(s) in the new Europe. Kenan Malik
Shadow of the fatwa


Jürgen Habermas
The dialectic of secularization.
Stephen H. Jones
The deep slumber of decided opinions. Rowan Williams and the Sharia controversy
Jean-Louis Schlegel
Nicolas Sarkozy, the laïcité and the religions
Abdul-Rehman Malik
Take me to your leader. Post-secular society and the Islam industry
Claus Leggewie
Between national Church and religious supermarket. Muslim organizations in Germany and the problem of representation
Sven-Eric Liedman
The rebirth of religion and enchanting materialism
Josè Casanova
Religion, European secular identities, and European integration
Danièle Hervieu-Léger
The role of religion in establishing social cohesion
Jan Philipp Reemtsma
Must we respect religiosity? On questions of faith and the pride of the secular society
Klaus Eder
European secularization: A special route to post-secular society?
Klaus Eder, Giancarlo Bosetti
Post-secularism: A return to the public sphere
Isolde Charim
Culture as battlefield
Ètienne Balibar
Discords in the French laicity
Olivier Mongin, Jean-Louis Schlegel
The legislation of 1905
Ernest Gellner
Religion and the profane
Ramin Jahanbegloo
Beyond the clash of intolerances
Nilüfer Göle
The Islamist identity. Islam, European public space, and civility
Olivier Roy
Islamic evangelism. Islam in Europe
Éric Rouleau
Power and religion. Political Islam
Abdesselam Cheddadi
The question of tolerance in Islamic societies
Rachid Benzine, Luca Sebastiani
The new paths of modern Islam
Tahar Ben Jelloun
Pride and prejudice. On the incompatibility of religion and humour
Seyla Benhabib, Giancarlo Bosetti
Beliefs in the US. Between new fears and old responses
Mattias Martinson
Theology of tidal waves. A post-humanist interpretation
The real issue is not an intellectual or theoretical question about Islam, but the religious practices of Muslims. The forms of religiosity in Islam today are more or less the same as those found in Catholicism, Protestantism, and even Judaism. Contemporary adherents insist more on personal faith and individual spiritual experience. Such "born again" believers rebuild their identities from the perspective of their rediscovery of religion.

With Islamic fundamentalism, too, we are not witnessing a traditional religion asserting itself against the Christian West. When the Taliban came to power in Afghanistan in 1996, they had an excellent relationship with the Americans, and Westerners could travel freely in Afghanistan between 1996 and 1998.

The Taliban were not fighting Western culture, but traditional Afghan culture. Why forbid owning songbirds? Why ban kites? The rationale was one common to all forms of fundamentalism: this world exists only to prepare the believer for salvation. The state's role is not to ensure social justice and the rule of law, but to create opportunities – even if they are coercive – for believers to find their way to salvation.

The Taliban's argument was simple: if your bird starts singing while you are praying, you will be distracted and your prayer will be nullified. If you are a good Muslim, you will start again from the beginning. But, since we are not sure that you are a good Muslim, it is easier to forbid owning songbirds, so that they cannot jeopardize your salvation.

Similarly, kites get tangled in trees, and if you climb the tree to free it, you might look over your neighbor's wall and see a woman without her veil, which would put you in a sinful state. Why risk burning in hell for a kite? Better to ban them.

Fundamentalism is thus not a protest by original cultures under threat; it is the praise of these cultures' disappearance. So it is a grave mistake to link modern forms of fundamentalism with the idea of a clash of cultures or civilizations. Young people do not become fundamentalists because their parents' culture is ignored by Western civilization. Fundamentalist religiosity is individual and generational, a rebellion against the religion of one's parents.

Of course, religious fundamentalists of whatever stripe often emphasize similar codes, norms, and values. When Pim Fortuyn in Holland decided to wage a campaign against Muslim influence, he was defending sexual freedom, not traditional Christian values. But on this subject and others – such as family and abortion – religious Muslims in Europe side with conservative Christians.

Nevertheless, such commonalities do not explain political and radical Islam. Osama Bin Laden is much more the expression of deracination than of a tradition of political violence in Islam. Muhammad Atta, Zacharias Moussaoui, and Kamel Daoudi were "born again" in Marseilles, London, and Montreal, not in Egypt or Morocco (and they all broke ties with their families).

Moreover, young radicals go to fight in Bosnia, Chechnya, Afghanistan, or Kashmir rather than in their countries of origin, because they do not regard the Middle East as the heart of a Muslim civilization that is under siege by crusaders. They live in a global world, and they do not perceive themselves as Middle Easterners.

The irrelevance of traditional culture explains the growing number of converts in all the recently discovered radical networks. The members of the Beghal network in France were roughly one-third converts. The French police arrested a German citizen with a Polish name in connection with the terrorist attack on the synagogue in Djerba, Tunisia. Richard Reid, who tried to blow up a British airplane; José Padilla, accused of plotting a "dirty bomb" attack in the United States; and John Walker Lindh, the American Taliban, are all converts.

In Europe, conversion is typically confined to underprivileged neighbourhoods, populated by young people with no job prospects and who generally live in a small underground economy of delinquency. The radical and violent Left in Europe today has abandoned these zones of social exclusion. Radicals used to learn to handle a Kalashnikov and hijack planes with the Palestinians. Now they learn to handle a Kalashnikov and hijack planes with Al Qaeda.

Their quest for mythic, messianic, transnational movements of liberation remains the same, as does the enemy: the American imperial colossus. They are the product not of Western history or Middle Eastern history, but the fusion of all histories, of globalization. They are at home in a homeless world.


This is a commentary distributed by Project Syndicate and based on the longer, original essay "Islam in Europe: Clash of Religions or Convergence of Religiosities?" published in Krzysztof Michalski (ed.), Conditions of European Solidarity, vol. II: Religion in the New Europe, Central European University Press 2006.

 



Published 2006-08-17


Original in
First published in Project Syndicate, April 2004

Contributed by Transit
© Olivier Roy/Project Syndicate, Institute for Human Sciences
© Eurozine
 

Focal points

Climate of change?

http://www.eurozine.com/comp/focalpoints/ecopolitics.html
Green turnaround or business as usual in the global hothouse? Debating the politics of climate change. [more]

Dilemma 89

http://www.eurozine.com/comp/focalpoints/dilemma89.html
1989: not only historic moment of liberation, but also political and social dilemma for the present day. [more]

European histories

http://www.eurozine.com/comp/focalpoints/eurohistories.html
European solidarity requires a common history that accommodates the experiences of East and West. [more]

Editor's choice

Anders Ramsay
Marx? Which Marx?

http://www.eurozine.com/articles/2009-12-21-ramsay-en.html
Marx's naturalistic understanding of value has led interpreters to overlook the role played by credit, writes Anders Ramsay. [more]

Ewa Hess, Hennric Jokeit
Neurocapitalism

http://www.eurozine.com/articles/2009-11-24-jokeit-en.html
In a society that confronts the self with its own shortcomings, neuroscience serves an expanding market. [more]

Zoltan Tabori
Guns, fire and ditches

http://www.eurozine.com/articles/2009-12-15-tabori-en.html
On the spiral of anti-Roma violence in small communities facing increasing competition for employment and education. [more]

Literature

Katharina Raabe
As the fog lifted

http://www.eurozine.com/articles/2009-10-08-raabe-en.html
In the twenty years since the fall of communism, literature has been lifting the fog settled over eastern central Europe. [more]

Literary perspectives
The re-transnationalization of literary criticism

Eurozine's series of essays aims to provide an overview of diverse literary landscapes in Europe. Covered as yet: Croatia, Sweden, Austria, Estonia, Ukraine, Northern Ireland, Slovenia, the Netherlands and Hungary. [more]

Behind the headlines

Memorial
National images of the past

http://www.eurozine.com/2008-12-05-memorial-en.html
An appeal by the winners of the Sakharov Prize 2009 for a platform for historical reconciliation. [more]

Mykola Riabchuk
Metaphors of betrayal

http://www.eurozine.com/articles/2009-10-14-riabchuk-en.html
Any policy towards the Ukraine-Russia conflict that downplays values is fundamentally flawed, writes Mykola Riabchuk. [more]

Conferences

Eurozine emerged from an informal network dating back to 1983. Since that time, a variety of European cultural magazines have met once a year in European cities to exchange ideas and experiences. In the meantime, approximately 100 periodicals from almost every European country have become involved in these meetings.
European histories
The 22nd European Meeting of Cultural Journals
Vilnius, 8-11 May 2009

http://www.eurozine.com/comp/focalpoints/vilnius_european_histories.html
The 22nd European Meeting of Cultural Journals took place in Vilnius, Lithuania, 8 to 11 May 2009. Under the heading "European Histories", the Eurozine conference explored the role of history and memory in forming new identities in a Europe in change. [more]

Multimedia

http://www.eurozine.com/comp/multimedia.html
Multimedia section including videos of past Eurozine conferences in Vilnius (2009) and Sibiu (2007). [more]


powered by publick.net